The world of content material web sites has modified dramatically over the previous few years, and Paul Thomas has been on the forefront of those shifts.
With over 25 years of expertise in constructing and promoting web sites, Paul has efficiently pivoted from conventional content-based websites to a subscription mannequin.
His first subscription website, launched in 2018, now earns over $100k a 12 months and attracts practically 5 million guests yearly. His second website, launched two years in the past, is on observe to generate $30k to $40k per 12 months with fewer guests however a better income per person.
On this interview, Paul shares how he constructed two thriving membership websites with out counting on search engine marketing and what classes different entrepreneurs can be taught from his journey.
Watch the Full Episode
Paul’s journey in on-line entrepreneurship started within the late 90s when he constructed and bought a number of content material web sites. However by 2018, he noticed the writing on the wall—counting on search engine marketing for visitors was changing into riskier as competitors elevated, social media dominated, and search engine algorithms modified unpredictably.
He determined to transition to a subscription-based mannequin, specializing in viewers retention reasonably than one-time web site visits.
His first subscription website, launched in 2018, now earns over $100,000 a 12 months and attracts practically 5 million guests yearly. His second website, launched two years in the past, is on observe to generate $30,000 to $40,000 per 12 months with fewer guests however a better income per person. The important thing takeaway? A well-structured subscription mannequin can considerably increase long-term income in comparison with ad-based content material websites.
One of the vital crucial points of Paul’s success is area of interest choice. Not all subjects lend themselves nicely to a membership mannequin. In accordance with Paul, the best area of interest ought to:
- Have a devoted viewers that seeks ongoing data or interplay.
- Supply refreshable content material that retains individuals coming again (e.g., hobby-based communities, interactive instruments, or usually up to date business information).
- Present a transparent motive for customers to pay—whether or not it’s unique content material, premium instruments, or group options.
Paul cites examples like AllTrails, Fishbrain, and FunTrivia—platforms that constantly supply new content material or interactive instruments that encourage long-term engagement.
Monetization Technique: Freemium Mannequin and Pricing
Quite than gatekeeping all content material behind a paywall, Paul makes use of a freemium mannequin, giving freely a good portion of content material totally free whereas reserving premium options for paying members. This strategy permits him to construct belief with guests earlier than changing them into subscribers.
In the case of pricing, Paul prefers low-cost, high-volume memberships over high-ticket subscriptions. His first website initially charged simply $2.50 monthly, later growing to a tiered mannequin starting from $4 to $20 monthly. Moreover, he presents an annual plan that costs barely above the common six-month retention interval, encouraging extra upfront funds.
Driving Visitors: A Social-First Method (No search engine marketing!)
Whereas many web site homeowners deal with search engine marketing to drive visitors, Paul took a totally completely different strategy—ignoring search engine marketing altogether. As an alternative, he constructed his viewers via Fb and YouTube:
- Fb Teams: He actively engaged in niche-related Fb communities, offering beneficial insights with out direct promoting. Over time, this constructed model consciousness and belief, main members to go to his website.
- YouTube: He repurposed content material into video format, utilizing delicate call-to-actions to drive viewers again to his web site.
His social-first technique has allowed him to scale visitors to almost 5 million guests per 12 months with out worrying about Google’s algorithm adjustments.
Changing Guests into E-mail Subscribers and Paying Members
As soon as guests land on his website, Paul’s main purpose is capturing their e-mail handle. Quite than utilizing conventional lead magnets, he presents customers a free membership tier that grants entry to extra content material in trade for an e-mail sign-up. This technique has been far more practical than typical opt-in types.
His e-mail technique follows a 5:1 ratio, sending 5 content-rich emails earlier than making a premium supply. He’s additionally discovered that being extra aggressive with premium upsells has led to greater conversions with out alienating his viewers.
Key Takeaways from Paul’s Success
- search engine marketing Isn’t Every part – It’s potential to construct a thriving website via social engagement and viewers retention as an alternative of search visitors.
- Freemium Works – Providing beneficial free content material builds belief and creates a pure transition to paid memberships.
- Decide the Proper Area of interest – Select a distinct segment the place individuals want ongoing content material or instruments, making certain long-term retention.
- Group is Key – Interact along with your viewers in boards, Fb teams, and YouTube to construct model recognition.
- E-mail is the Final Converter – Upon getting a customer’s e-mail, you management the connection and may nurture them into premium subscribers.
Paul’s technique is proof that with the fitting strategy, content material websites can thrive with out counting on Google. His long-term five-year dedication mannequin has led to spectacular outcomes, and his newest venture is projected to surpass his first website’s success. If you happen to’re trying to construct a sustainable on-line enterprise, his insights on subscription fashions supply a beneficial blueprint.
Hyperlinks & Sources
